As most of those close to me know, I have officially begun my foray into a post-baccalaureate pre-medical education (i.e. a fancy way of saying I’m taking pre-requisites to apply for physician assistant or medical school). Those who know this also probably know that science and math have never been my strong suit and thus, this new undertaking is absolutely terrifying to me.
In college I was of the attitude that I should study what I enjoyed and it would thusly lead to a career I enjoyed. Well, after 4 years out of college I have come to realize this is not the case. I absolutely loved all of the classes I took for my Political Science and German majors as well as electives I took in other foreign languages and humanities courses. And I succeeded at them. Foreign languages have always come easily to me and politics/international relations involve a large amount of analytical writing, something I’ve also found I’m good at. And yet both enjoying my coursework and succeeding in it have not led to a satisfactory career path. I won’t delve into my rant against office jobs and computer work at the moment, but the end result after 4 years is that I can’t think of a job I could do using my degree (or an advanced degree in the same field) that I would enjoy more or equally to working in health care, an interest I’ve had for nearly 10 years but avoided precisely because of the intimidating coursework required.
Given the fact that I have, in the past, dreaded and struggled with science and math, I am open to any insights I can come up with as to why this has been the case, or why I suppose, some succeed while others struggle and what can be done about it. And yet, one theory that I have come across is infuriating to me. I have encountered the discussion twice now in the last two weeks that women struggle in science and math because of persisting stereotypes placed upon our gender. In particular, this article Study Suggests Simple Fix to Help Women Succeed in Science (two years old, granted) on PBS offers a solution to the achievement gap among men and women in science: a “values-affirming writing exercise” for female students to take their minds off of the “stereotype threat”. Supposedly a woman who completes this writing exercise will then perform on exams with ease, creating a snowballing effect throughout the semester.
Speaking strictly of my own experiences, never once have I attributed my struggles in science and math courses to my gender. Never once have I felt stereotyped by instructors (male or female) or members of the opposite sex based on my gender. And yet articles such as these suggest that it is in fact the case that part of my struggles stem from overarching stereotypes about the capabilities of my sex. To me this goes right back to suggesting that I struggle because I am a woman and at that I take offense. The fact that the PBS article suggests I simply need to perform a writing exercise to “bolster [my] sense of self-worth and personal integrity” is to me, bullshit and does not come close to a respectable discussion on the topic. How is an approach such as this helping our society to overcome the achievement gap among genders if it continues to focus on gender as the root of the problem?
Perhaps I am simply defensive of my own learning abilities. I haven’t done research beyond this one article and a similar discussion I heard on NPR that suggested that women with more feminine names will be more harshly stereotyped and thus perform more poorly than their sisters with less feminine names (this is just as absurd to me). I realize that the article is reporting on the results of a scientific study and am trying to be respectful of the fact that there is thus some credibility attached to it. I also respect the fact that we are as a society concerned that there is still an achievement gap among men and women in science and that we want to change this. But I’m curious to see what other theories and opinions are out there regarding learning abilities and capabilities beyond a gender-based approach because the assumption that I struggle because I am a woman is unacceptable to me.